Docket | UNC Student Supreme Court

This page shows the Court’s Docket going back to the February Term of 2008 (dispositions between 1969 and 2008 are available in Volume One of the Reporter). The final disposition of the Court, if available in the archive when the cases were recovered, will be bolded. In 2022, the Court switched to a different mode of formatting dispositions from previous terms. The Docket will contain Orders of the Court. Unless the document is an Opinion of the Court (which can be found in the appropriate tab), the document is not binding as precedent.

2024 Term

Began April 2024. Cases will appear here when filed.

2023 Term

Case	Docket No., Date, Files
23-001 Gary v. B.O.E.	1 — October 31, 2023 — Complaint 2 — October 31, 2023 — Motion for Expedited Review 3 — October 31, 2023 — Motion for TRO 4 — October 31, 2023 — Summons 5 — November 3, 2023 — Answer 6 — November 3, 2023 — Motion for Summary of Judgement 7 — November 10, 2023 — Brief of the Undergraduate Senate as Amicus Curiae 8 — November 14, 2023 — Per Curiam Opinion of the Court
23-002 Edwards v. B.O.E.	1 — January 19, 2024 — Notice of Intent to File 2 — January 20, 2024 — Complaint 3 — January 20, 2024 — Summons 4 — January 21, 2024 — Motion for TRO 5 — January 24, 2024 — Motion for Expedited Review 6 — January 24, 2024 — Order Rejecting Request for Outside Counsel 7 — January 24, 2024 — Answer 8 — January 26, 2024 — Motion to Strike 9 — January 26, 2024 — Defendant’s Response to Motion for TRO 10 — January 26, 2024 — Defendant’s Response to Motion to Strike 11 — January 26, 2024 — Motion Against Expedited Review 12 — January 27, 2024 — Order Denying Motion to Strike 13 — January 27, 2024 — Order Denying in Part Motion to Expedite 14 — January 29, 2024 — Plaintiff’s Response to Court Order 15 — February 1, 2024 — Order Denying Motion for TRO 16 — February 5, 2024 — Motion to Amend Answer 17 — February 19, 2024 — Opinion of the Court
23-003 Taylor, et al. v. B.O.E.	1 — February 1, 2024 — Complaint 2 — February 1, 2024 — Motion for Injunction 3 — February 2, 2024 — Order Denying Motion for Injunction 4 — February 2, 2024 — Summons 5 — February 3, 2023 — Motion Withdrawing Plaintiff Taylor 6 — February 5, 2024 — Motion to Dismiss 7 — February 7, 2024 — Order Dismissing Case

2022 Term

Case	Docket No., Date, Files
22-001 Erdal v. Vann	1 — June 12, 2022 — Notice of Intent to File 2 — June 12, 2022 — Order Establishing Complaint Due Date 3 — June 25, 2022 — Order Dismissing Case as Moot
22-002 Pearce v. Miller	1 — September 12, 2022 — Notice of Intent to File 2 — September 12, 2022 — Order Establishing Complaint Due Date 3 — September 12, 2022 — PAPERLESS ORDER: plaintiff shall clarify: (1) whether the consolidation of Defendant Worley under Case No. 22–002 is the intended outcome of their successive submissions of the Notice of Intent to File Form on HeelLife or whether they intended to file a separate case against Defendant Worley, and (2) whether or not plaintiff intends to include further defendants in this case, and (3) further clarification about whether they intended to name themselves as a defendant in an action in their submission of Notice of Intent to File at 7:07 p.m. or whether the 7:09 p.m. submission was intended to be a correction of the previous submission. 4 — September 12, 2022 — Plaintiff’s Response to Paperless Order 5 — September 19, 2022 — Complaint 6 — September 19, 2022 — Summons CONSOLIDATED INTO 22–007
22-003 Pearce v. Worley	1 — September 12, 2022 — Notice of Intent to File 2 — September 13, 2022 — Order Establishing Complaint Due Date 3 — September 19, 2022 — Complaint 4 — September 19, 2022 — Summons CONSOLIDATED INTO 22–007
22-004 Pearce v. Worley, et al.	1 — September 13, 2022 — Notice of Intent to File 2 — September 13, 2022 — Order Establishing Complaint Due Date 3 — September 16, 2022 — Motion for Extension 4 — September 17, 2022 — Statement of Justices Shue and Ewington Respecting the Grant of an Extension of Time 5 — September 17, 2022 — Order Granting Motion for Extension 6 — September 28, 2022 — Order Dismissing Case
22-005 Gary, et al. v. RHA Exec. Bd.	1 — September 13, 2022 — Notice of Intent to File 2 — September 13, 2022 — Order Establishing Complaint Due Date 3 — September 19, 2022 — Complaint 4 — September 19, 2022 — Summons CONSOLIDATED INTO 22–007
22–006 USG Senate v. Grodsky	1 — September 20, 2022 — Notice of Intent to File 2 — September 20, 2022 — Order establishing Complaint Due Date 3 — September 21, 2022 — Complaint 4 — September 21, 2022 — Summons 4 — September 21, 2022 — Answer 5 — September 21, 2022 — Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgement 6 — September 21, 2022 — Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgement and Dismissal 7 — September 30, 2022 — Opinion of the Court
22–007 Pearce, et al. v. RHA Exec. Bd., et al.	1 — September 27, 2022 — Order Consolidating Cases 22–002, –003, –005, and Appointing Counsel 2 — October 4, 2022 — Defendant’s Motion for an Extension of Time to File an Answer 3 — October 9, 2022 — PAPERLESS ORDER: The motion for an extension of time is granted in part. Defendant’s Answer is now due at 11:59 p.m. on October 12, 2022. No further extensions shall be granted before the deadline passes. Any further applications for extension must be filed past the deadline pursuant to III J. C. S. G. § 714. 4 — October 12, 2022 — Order Directing Executive Branches to Appoint Counsel 5 — October 25, 2022 — Order Establishing Answer Due Date Upon Change of Counsel 6 — October 31, 2022 — Answer and Motion to Dismiss 7 — November 2, 2022 — Plaintiff Pearce’s Brief in Opposition to Motion to Dismiss 8 — November 3, 2022 — Order Denying Motion to Dismiss 9 — November 5, 2022 — Scheduling Order Specifying Procedures 10 — November 6, 2022 — Plaintiff Pearce’s Exhibits 1–8 11 — November 7, 2022 — Plaintiff Pearce’s First Amended Complaint 12 — November 8, 2022 — Substitution Order 13 — November 10, 2022 — Answer to Amended Complaint 14 — November 18, 2022 — Defendants’ Exhibits 15 — November 19, 2022 — TRIAL held at 8:00 AM to 1:00 PM in the Kenan Mock Courtroom. Trial was open to the public. 16 — December 19, 2022 — Opinion of the Court 17 — January 19, 2023 — RHA Statement to the Court
22-008 Robinson v. Bass, et al.	1 — February 1, 2023 — Complaint 2 — February 1, 2023 — Summons 3 — February 3, 2023 — Motion for TRO 4 — February 3, 2023 — Motion for Expedited Hearing 5 — February 4, 2023 — Order Denying TRO 6 — February 5, 2023 — PAPERLESS ORDER: On February 5, 2023, David Bass announced his withdrawal from the Student Body President Election. This case is DISMISSED as moot. 7 — February 5, 2023 — Plaintiff’s Motion to Dismiss as Moot

2021 Term

Docket No.	Files
21-001 Tweden v. B.O.E., et al.	February 16, 2022 — Notice of Intent to File February 18, 2022 — Order Establishing Complaint Due Date February 28, 2022 — Order Dismissing Case

2018 Term

Docket No.	Files
18-001 Garg, et al. v. Debnath, et al.	Formal Complaint

2017 Term

Docket No.	Files
17-001 Echeverria v. Adkins, et al.	Order Denying Motion to Dismiss Opinion
17-002 McClellan v. Joyner, et al.	Default Judgement Order

2016 Term

Docket No.	Files
16-001 Russell v. Berger, et al.	Complaint Final Defendant Answer Opinion
16-002 Nail v. Kushner, et al.	Order Granting Injunction Order Lifting Injunction
16-003 Nail v. Kushner, et al.	Order Rejecting Appeal
16-004 McKnight v. Kushner, et al.	Order Rejecting Appeal
16-005 McKnight v. Kushner, et al.	Order Rejecting Appeal
16-006 Broadhurst v. Kushner, et al.	Order Granting Injunction Order Regarding Complaint
16-007 Hopping v. Grier, et al.	Order Rejecting Appeal
16-008 Vigil v. Residence Hall Association	Complaint Amended Complaint Answer

2012 Term

Docket No.	Files
12-001 Brady v. Leimensoll and Myrick	Complaint Amended Complaint Summons Answer Plaintiff Motion to Subpoena Motion for Temporary Restraining Order Order Denying Temporary Restraining Order Defendant Motion for Summary Judgement Withdrawal of Complaint Order Dismissing Case
12-002 Anastas-King, et al. v. Comparato	Complaint Summons Defendants Motion to Dismiss Plaintiff Motion to Subpoena Documents Defendant Memorandum Plaintiff Affidavit Plaintiff Exhibit 1 Plaintiff Exhibit 2 Plaintiff Exhibit 3 Plaintiff Exhibit 4 Affidavit of Best Affidavit of Braxton Affidavit of Caison Affidavit of Crayton Affidavit of McClelland Plaintiff Motion to Subpoena Witnesses Plaintiff Brief Arguing Against Motion to Dismiss Order Granting Subpoena for Documents Order Granting Subpoena for Witnesses Plaintiffs Motion to Dismiss Order Dismissing Case

2010 Term

Docket No.	Files
10-001 Ingram v. Phillips, et al.	Complaint Summons Return of Service Brady Answer Swofford Answer Sundaram Answer Patel Answer Flood Answer Phillips Answer Order Dismissing Improper Defendants Revised Answer Motion to Amend Order Granting Motion to Amend Amended Complaint Answer to Amended Complaint Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss 1 Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss 2 Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss 3 Defendant’s Brief Defendant’s Motion for Subpoena Defendant’s Subpoena Withdrawal of Complaint Order Granting Motion to Dismiss
10-002 Horowitz, et al. v. Medlin and Phillips	Complaint Summons Injunction Answer Revised Answer Plaintiff’s Motion for Extension of Time Defendant’s Motion for Extension of Time Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss Order Granting Extension of Time Plaintiff’s Motion for Subpoena Defendant’s Brief Plaintiff’s Motion to Amend Complaint Order Granting Motion for Leave to Amend Complaint Amended Complaint Plaintiff’s Second Motion for Extension Defendant’s Second Motion to Dismiss Order Denying Motion to Dismiss Plaintiff’s Subpoena Defendant’s Motion for Subpoena Defendant’s Subpoena Order Granting Second Extension Order Granting Withdrawal as to Phillips Order Granting Plaintiff’s Motion to Dismiss as to Phillips Withdrawal of Complain as to Medlin Order Granting Withdrawal of Complain as to Medlin
10-003 Santoro v. Phillips	Complaint Motion for Injunction Summons Injunction Defendants Motion to Dismiss Answer Plaintiff’s Motion for Extension Defendants Motion for Extension Revised Answer Revised Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss Order Granting Extension Revised Plaintiff’s Brief Defendant’s Brief Order Granting Motion to Dismiss

2009 Term

Docket No.	Files
09-001 Danforth v. Jones	Complaint Withdrawal Order Dismissing Case
09-002 Dexter v. Levin-Manning	Complaint Motion for Temporary Injunction Summons Motion for Subpoena Order Denying Motion for Temporary Injunction Answer Motion to Dismiss Minutes of Pre-Trial Hearing Order Dismissing Case
09-003 Levin-Manning v. Gillooly	Complaint Summons Plaintiff’s Motion to Dismiss
09-004 Keune v. Gillooly	Complaint Amended Complaint Summons Order Denying Temporary Injunction Motion to Dismiss Order Dismissing Case
09-005 Holgate v. Gillooly	Motion for Injunction Order Granting Injunction Complaint Summons Joinder Order
09-006 Seelinger v. Gillooly	Motion for Injunction Complaint Summons Order Granting Injunction Joinder Order
09-007 Holgate and Seelinger v. Gillooly	Joinder Order Answer Motion to Dismiss Notice of Pretrial Hearing Plaintiff’s Brief Minutes of Pretrial Hearing Order Dismissing Case
09-008 Holgate v. Gillooly	Complaint Summons Answer Notice of Pretrial Hearing Minutes of Pretrial Hearing Trial Transcript Decision Announcement Opinion

2008 Term

Docket No.	Files
08-001 Wohlford v. Morgan	Establishment of Complaint Due Date Complaint Summons Answer Motion to Dismiss Order Dismissing Case
08-002 Wohlford v. Morgan	Establishment of Complaint Due Date Complaint Summons Answer Motion to Subpoena Evidence Subpoena Amended Complaint Second Answer Motion to Subpoena Testimony Subpoena of Morgan Order to Submit Briefs Plaintiff’s Brief Defendant’s Brief Opinion
08-003 Klein v. Morgan	Establishment of Complaint Due Date Amendment of Complaint Due Date Complaint Summons Answer Defendant’s Subpoena for Evidence Order Granting Subpoena for Evidence Opinion
08-004 Nichols v. Raynor	Motion for Injunction Amended Motion for Injunction Injunction Appendix Temporary Injunction Complaint Answer Motion to Dismiss Order Denying Motion to Dismiss Defendant’s Brief Plaintiff’s Brief Opinion
08-005 Bilbao v. Morgan	Complaint Motion to Dismiss Answer Motion to Subpoena Order Dismissing Case
08-006 Bilbao v. Morgan	Complaint Answer Opinion
08-007 Project Dinah v. Congress	Complaint Answer Opinion